Preview

Siberian Law Review

Advanced search

The Procedure of Termination of the Criminal Case (Criminal Prosecution) on Rehabilitation Bases in the Russian Federation and Mongolia

https://doi.org/10.19073/2658-7602-2019-16-3-364-368

Abstract

The article describes the features of the modern criminal procedure of Mongolia, which consist in the absence of the stage of initiation of criminal proceedings, confluence of a decision of initiation of criminal proceedings and decision about prosecution as an accused, in existence of uniform termination procedure of investigation of the criminal cases subject to termination or referral to court. Comparative legal analysis of rehabilitating grounds for termination of criminal case (criminal prosecution) is carried out. The content of criminal procedural activities at the end of the investigation is considered. The procedure for appealing against decisions on termination of the criminal case is researched. It is characterized by a lack of judicial control in pre-trial proceedings in Mongolia. The procedure and law enforcement practice of realization of the right to rehabilitation is analyzed. The conclusion that departmental regulation hinders its implementation is made. The Authors state that the procedure for termination of the criminal case provided by the Criminal procedure code of Mongolia contains fairly extended guarantees of establishing the truth. The normative regulation completely excludes multiple transfer of the criminal case from the police to prosecutor in the event of discrepancy in the assessment of the qualification of the crime and the completeness of the investigation. The absence of a procedure for the termination of criminal prosecution due to non-involvement is a serious drawback of Mongolian legislation. In general, the mechanism of termination of the criminal case in the criminal procedure legislation of Mongolia is conceptually more consistent and logical, but in terms of elaboration of procedural mechanisms is much inferior to Russian legislation.

About the Authors

P. V. Kozlovskii
Omsk Academy of the Ministry of the Interior of Russia
Russian Federation


G. Rentsendorj
University of Law Enforcement Services of the Ministry of Justice and Internal Affairs of Mongolia
Russian Federation


References

1. Дочия Р. М. Современные проблемы института прекращения уголовного дела (уголовного преследования): теоретические, правовые и прикладные вопросы : дис.. канд. юрид. наук. Омск : Ом. акад. МВД России, 2004. 168 с.

2. Химичева Г. П. Досудебное производство по уголовным делам: концепция совершенствования уголовно-процессуальной деятельности : моногр. М. : Экзамен, 2003. 350 с.

3. Батцэрэн Б., Эрдэнэбат Г. Монгол улсын Эруу болон Эруугийн хянан шиидвэрлэх тухай шинэ хуулийн албан бус тайлбар. Улаанбаатар : УБ нэгдсэн хэвлэх уйлдвэр, 2017. 760 х.

4. Бат-эрдэнэ Б. Монгол улсын ЭБШЭЗ дэх мерден байцаалтын эрх зуйн ундэс // Монголын төр, эрх зүй сэтгуул. 2017. № 4. Х. 15-16.

5. Бат-эрдэнэ Б. Монгол улсын эруугиин байцаан шиитгэх эрх зуй: сурах бичиг. Улаанбаатар : УБ нэгдсэн хэвлэх уйлдвэр, 2002. Х. 98-99.

6. Зумбэрэллхам Б. Монгол улсын эруугиин байцаан шиитгэх эрх зуйн ундсэн асуудлууд:.сурах бичиг. Улаанбаатар : УБ нэгдсэн хэвлэх уйлдвэр, 2017. 350 х.

7. Нарангэрэл С. Монгол улсын эрх зуйн сурах бичиг. Улаанбаатар : УБ нэгдсэн хэвлэх уйлдвэр, 2004. 247 х.


Review

For citations:


Kozlovskii P.V., Rentsendorj G. The Procedure of Termination of the Criminal Case (Criminal Prosecution) on Rehabilitation Bases in the Russian Federation and Mongolia. Siberian Law Review. 2019;16(3):364-368. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.19073/2658-7602-2019-16-3-364-368

Views: 478


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2658-7602 (Print)
ISSN 2658-7610 (Online)