The Formation and Development of the Legal Status of a Consumer of Paid Medical Services in the Russian Health Care System in the XVIII – Early XX Centuries

The socio-economic situation in Russia over the past decades has undergone serious changes that could not but affect the health system. There have been prerequisites for the development of private medicine, which has been supported by the state. Currently, there is an increase in the share of medical services provided on a paid basis. Widespread private practice, covering the chronological period of the Russian Empire, was interpreted by the authorities in the Soviet period as a relic of the capitalist system, contrary to the basic principles of proper health care organization. The Soviet period of Russian history appears to us as a chronological gap, that is, a time gap that characterizes the specifics of the linear existence of paid medical services.
In this regard, it seems relevant and timely to conduct research on the historical aspects of the formation and development of the legal status of consumers of paid medical services in the Russian Empire. In our opinion, such research is of both theoretical and practical interest. The first is due to the lack of development of this topic in the historical and legal literature. The second one will allow us to identify existing shortcomings in legal regulation in the sphere of public health protection based on the generalization of historical experience and formulate practical recommendations for improving the legislation of the Russian Federation in this area.
From the perspective of this work, we aim to assess the legal status of consumers of paid medical services in the XVIII – early XX century, comprehensively examining such elements of legal status as rights, freedoms, interests and duties. The article analyzes the influence of belonging of the inhabitants of the Empire to a particular social group on the formation of the legal status of consumers of paid medical services. For the first time, the main types of rights of consumers of paid medical services are separated from the regulatory legal acts in the field of healthcare of the Russian Empire and formed into a group.
Based on the results of a detailed analysis, we conclude that in the Russian Empire, the duties of consumers of paid medical services took priority over the rights, since it was believed that if the obligations were met, the rights would exist regardless of their formal Declaration. The analysis helps to understand the development of regulation of health ser-vices and allows us to draw historical parallels with the existing regulatory framework of the health care system in Russia.

1. Budko A. A. Istoriya meditsiny Sankt-Peterburga XIX – nachala XX v. [The History of Medicine in St. Petersburg in the XIX – Early XX Centuries]. St. Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriya Publ., 2010. 400 p.

2. Dvenadtsatyi Pirogovskii s”ezd. Peterburg, 29 maya – 5 iyunya 1913 g. Vyp. 2. [The Twelfth Pirogov Congress. Petersburg, May 29 – June 5, 1913. Iss. 2]. St. Petersburg, 1913. 512 p.

3. Drgonets Ya., Khollender P. Sovremennaya meditsina i pravo [Modern Medicine and Law]. Moscow, Yuridicheskaya literatura Publ., 1991. 336 p.

4. Kodan S. V. Soslovnoe zakonodatel’stvo v politike rossiiskoi verkhovnoi vlasti (1800–1850-e gg.) [The Estate Legislation in the Policy of the Russian Supreme Government (1800–1850’s)]. Yuridicheskie issledovaniya – Legal Studies, 2012, no. 2, pp. 117–145. DOI: 10.7256/2305-9699.2012.2.152.

5. Kulikova S. G. Deyatel’nost’ zemstva v oblasti meditsiny i sanitarii (na primere Moskovskoi i Tverskoi gubernii) [The Activities of the Zemstvos in the Field of Medicine and Sanitation (on the Example of the Moscow and Tver Provinces)]. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser.: Istoriya – Herald of Tver State University. Series: History, 2019, no. 1 (49), pp. 19–34.

6. Markus M. A. Kratkoe rukovodstvo dlya vrachei k poznaniyu rossiiskikh zakonov, uchrezhdenii i gosudarstvennoi sluzhby, izdannoe predsedatelem Meditsinskogo soveta [A Short Guide for Doctors to the Knowledge of Russian Laws, Institutions and Public Service, Published by the Chairman of the Medical Council]. St. Petersburg, E. Prats’ Typography, 1843. 198 p.

7. Mysh M. I. Polozhenie o zemskikh uchrezhdeniyakh 12 iyunya 1890 goda so vsemi otnosyashchimisya k nemu uzakoneniyami, sudebnymi i pravitel’stvennymi raz”yasneniyami [Regulations on Zemstvo Institutions on June 12, 1890 with All Legalizations, Judicial and Government Explanations Related to It]. 5th ed. St. Petersburg, A. Benke’s Typography, 1910. 939 p.

8. Pristankova N. I. Pravovoe regulirovanie vrachebno-sanitarnoi deyatel’nosti v Rossiiskoi imperii: XIX – nachalo XX vv. Dis. kand. yurid. nauk [Legal Regulation of Medical and Sanitary Activities in the Russian Empire: XIX – Early XX Centuries. Cand. Legal Sci. Dis.]. St. Petersburg, 2007. 215 p.

9. Skorokhodov L. Ya. Kratkii ocherk istorii russkoi meditsiny [A Brief Outline of the History of Russian Medicine]. Leningrad, Prakticheskaya meditsina Publ., 1926. 262 p.

10. Smirnova E. M. Stanovlenie sistemy zdravookhraneniya v rossiiskoi provintsii, 1775–1914 gg. (po materialam regiona Verkhnei Volgi). Dis. d-ra ist. nauk [Formation of the Health Care System in the Russian Province, 1775–1914. (Based On Materials from the Upper Volga Region). Dr. Hist. Sci. Dis.]. Yaroslavl, 2017. 470 p.

11. Tregubov S. N. Ugolovnaya otvetstvennost’ vracha za vrachevanie bez soglasiya bol’nogo [Criminal Liability of a Doctor for Medical Treatment Without the Consent of the Patient]. St. Petersburg, Senat Typography, 1904. 54 p.

12. Khitrov A. A. Dom Romanovykh i rossiiskaya blagotvoritel’nost’. Vtoraya polovina XIX – nachalo XX veka: po materialam Sankt-Peterburga – Petrograda i Peterburgskoi – Petrogradskoi gubernii. Dis. d-ra ist. nauk [House of Romanovs and Russian Charity. Second Half of the XIX – Early XX Centuries: Based On Materials from St. Petersburg – Petrograd and St. Petersburg – Petrograd Province. Dr. Hist. Sci. Dis.]. St. Petersburg, 2009. 504 p.

13. Chistovich Ya. A. Ocherki iz istorii russkikh meditsinskikh uchrezhdenii XVIII stoletiya [Essays from the History of Russian Medical Institutions of the XVIII Century]. St. Petersburg, Ya. Trei’s Typography, 1870. 416 p.

14. Digby A. Restoring the balance: women physicians and the profession of medicine, 1850–1995. Medical History, 2003, no. 47 (1), pp. 130–131.

15. McCarthy L. Finding a Space for Women: The British Medical Association and Women Doctors in Australia, 1880–1939. Medical History, 2018, no. 62 (1), pp. 91–111. DOI: 10.1017/mdh.2017.74.

16. O’Brien J. The Obligation of Professional Men to Secrecy. British Medical Journal, 1860, no. 1 (159), p. 37.